He scored the winning goal against Sunderland in the semi-final that led to their first FA Cup finals appearance. He then moved to Everton, where he became a fan favorite. In 2012, after eight years with Everton, he signed with the New York Red Bulls of Major League Soccer. He scored the fastest goal in MLS history in October 2013, when he scored seven seconds into a game against the Houston Dynamo. He is the all-time top scorer on the Australian National Team.